G I Forum Solution Suggestion

Project name: G I Forum Solution Suggestion

List the objectives for the piece: Re instate Founding Chapter, force them to unify, put the money out in front of the membership for all to control (not just a few people), return National Administration to Corpus Christi (perfect example of Brain Drain)

Who will receive or see the piece?

South Texas, South Texas Politicos, GI Forum Founder Hector P Garcia Familia, Ram Chavez (Founding Chapter GI Forum ex Commander / re-elected Commander), Joe Ortiz (National GI Forum Civil Rights Director), Agnes Horne (title) , Tony Morales (National GI Forum Commander)

Explain the concept in one or two sentences:

Two Options; either the Founding Chapter will be erased or it will be reinstated.

Defiance will destroy, disband and certainly bring forth litigation on both civil and criminal fronts.

The path towards reinstatement begins with a very proud man swallowing a little pride and taking one for the team.

What themes or images come to mind?

A productive modernized Hector P Garcia building / program in Unity with Al Gonzalez Center a skatepark at the Memorial Coliseum and a boardwalk from Oso Pier to Cole Park

What are the main messages for the copy?

Supporting Ram Chavez is noble but will not produce positively for the Founding Chapter of the National GI Forum.

What kinds of illustrations will be used?

Hector P Garcia building with high grass

Timeline selected & created from Caller Times Articles

Garcia clinic status OK'd

City recognizes historical, cultural value of building

By Neal Falgoust Caller-Times
December 22, 2004

Dr. Hector P. Garcia's old Bright Street clinic has been designated a local historic and cultural landmark by the city, making it eligible for thousands of dollars in federal grants that could be used to turn it into a museum.

Hector Garcia's clinic was a hotbed of political activity in the 1960s and it was where Garcia and his comrades planned the legal strategy for the 1968 case Cisneros et. al. vs. CCISD. It was that case that set the stage for court-ordered school integration in Corpus Christi from 1976 to 1982.

Legacy of 'Dr. Hector' deserves better than this

The job of turning the civil-rights pioneer's medical office into a museum has been botched; put it in more capable hands.

July 28, 2005

Having the former offices of civil rights leader Dr. Hector P. Garcia go on the auction block would be a dismal turn for the historical legacy of a remarkable man. But the auction block may be one of the few ways to put the building on the city's Westside in new hands and preserve the vision of a museum honoring Garcia.

Even if the auction doesn't take place as scheduled next week, it's time for the present title holders of Garcia's office, the National Archives & Historical Foundation of the American GI Forum and its chairman, Amador Garcia, to step aside. New leadership should be given the opportunity to make the museum vision happen.

The promises made by Amador Garcia, foundation chairman, have a hollow sound, given the record of inaction. The late doctor's widow, Wanda Garcia, is owed $12,000 on a $20,000 promissory note for Garcia's offices signed in 2000. There have been no payments to Mrs. Garcia in years. Her attorney has now filed foreclosure papers, and the building, barring payment, will be sold on the courthouse steps next week.

At this stage of her life, Mrs. Garcia deserves to be living in peace and being honored in her own right, not chasing down deadbeat accounts. As the woman who stood beside Garcia while he fought in the public arena, she deserves far better treatment than this.

Yet even if the foundation and foundation chairman Garcia manage to stave off foreclosure, their stewardship is badly - and sadly - lacking. Nearly $2,000 in back taxes is owed on the building because of an inexplicable oversight in filing for tax-exempt status. In addition, Garcia, a lawyer, offers in defense explanations of missed deadlines for grant applications, pilfered funds and sagging donations. The vandalized and boarded-up building where so much Hispanic history has occurred is a direct reflection of the shabby treatment Dr. Garcia's memory has received.

Good intentions are simply not enough. The job of respecting Dr. Garcia's memory and educating new generations about his life and work is more important than any one person or group of persons. Chairman Garcia can honor the good doctor, his cousin, by handing over the reins to someone else.

Garcias get paid for Dr. Hector's office

Daughters are critical of Amador Garcia, leader of foundation

By Sara Lee Fernandez Caller-Times
August 1, 2005

Dr. Hector P. Garcia's widow on Monday received the balance of the money owed to her by the foundation created to honor her husband, preventing foreclosure on his clinic.

The $12,000 balance of a $20,000 promissory note Wanda Fusillo Garcia financed in 2000 to the National Archives & Historical Foundation of the American GI Forum was wired to her trust fund by the 2 p.m. deadline, said Cecilia Akers, one of Dr. Garcia's daughters.

"She is very happy that this chapter in her life is closed," said Akers, who like her mother lives in San Antonio.

Akers and her older sister, Wanda Garcia, who lives in Austin, said they believe there is a lack of commitment to preserving their father's memory and said Amador Garcia should step aside and allow someone else to lead the foundation.

They cited the deteriorated state of their father's clinic at 1319 Bright St., the three years of nonpayment and a lack of communication by Amador Garcia.

"The Archives needs leadership and direction," Akers said. "The community has lost confidence in (Amador Garcia) and I think the archives are going to have a hard time seeing this project to completion."

With the promissory note paid, the foundation is now free to make major changes to the clinic.

Wanda Garcia said it was her father's wish that Amador Garcia head the foundation, of which she is a board member. However, she has never been notified of a board meeting and is disappointed that the situation got to the point where the family had to foreclose on the building to get Amador Garcia's attention.

Akers said she would like to see the two Corpus Christi chapters of the American GI Forum and the Archives work together to restore the building and make it into a museum.

"I think that if they unite and pool their resources we can see my father's dream to completion," Akers said.

National GI Forum expels Chavez

U.S. organization accused him of acting improperly;he vows to fight the action

By Sara Lee Fernandez Caller-Times
August 10, 2005

Ram Chavez, commander of the Dr. Hector P. Garcia Founders Chapter of the American GI Forum, has been expelled from the national organization, which will affect his status as leader of the original chapter.

Chavez was removed from the American GI Forum of the United States on July 28 after a panel hearing during the national convention in Anaheim, Calif.

He is appealing the decision.

What was the outcome?

"I will have documents and records but I will not hold this appeal in public," Chavez said. "I will do it internally as every organization should do."

But now he is willing to take this internal issue to court?

It is not internal when public money is involved.

According to the written decision the panel issued last month, Chavez was found guilty of improperly removing Founders Chapter members from the organization after former member Willie Davila requested financial documents in 2002.

Because he was expelled from the organization, Chavez will not be eligible for re-election as the Founders Chapter commander during the upcoming annual local elections the first week of September..

Joe Ortiz, civil rights director for the GI Forum's national organization, represented Davila during last month's hearing. He said Davila was a member of the Founders Chapter for about 10 years before he was removed, while Dr. Xico Garcia was commander.

Chavez, 59, was accused of acting improperly because he influenced Dr. Xico Garcia to have Davila removed after he questioned the finances, Ortiz said.

City gives $20,000 to fix Garcia clinic

By Neal Falgoust Caller-Times
August 11, 2005

City Manager Skip Noe said officials have scraped together more than $20,000 in federal grant money to help rehabilitate the clinic, which for many years was the headquarters of the local Hispanic civil rights movement.

At the heart of the fight are allegations levied against Garcia that he has allowed the clinic to slip into disrepair, despite having raised thousands of dollars to renovate it.

Garcia acknowledged Thursday that he needs help in developing a business plan and proposals to solicit donations.

"What we need is somebody who knows how to do that," he said. "I'm not the guy."

JK: Garcia cannot be the only one who has neglected the building of the past 20 years. It has been in disrepair from before he took possession?

Garcia said the foundation might need to hire someone to do that work. He added that he would be willing to relinquish ownership of the building to Texas A&M University-Corpus Christi once the renovations occur so that the building could be used as an education center. The university is the official depository for the doctor's papers.

The building, at the corner of Morgan Avenue and Bright Street, is where activists planned the strategy for the landmark 1968 case Cisneros et. al. v. CCISD, which set the stage for courtordered school integration in Corpus Christi from 1976 to 1982. The building has been under the care of the National Archives & Historical Foundation of the GI Forum, which was set up in 1978 as a fundraising arm of the larger GI Forum - which was established by Dr. Garcia.

.

Garcia said the division within the GI Forum has hampered rehab efforts.

Members of the Dr. Hector P. Garcia Founders Chapter of the GI Forum have challenged Amador Garcia's leadership in recent weeks and worked behind the scenes to wrestle ownership of the building away from the foundation.

The struggle dates back to 1999, when the Founders Chapter, led by Dr. Garcia's brother Xico, sued the foundation and its directors, charging that the chapters were being denied access to money in the building fund.

The foundation settled the lawsuit for $50,000, leaving about $50,000 remaining in the foundation's coffers.

GI Forum foundation seeks 9-year audit

Work is expected to last about month, cost about $1,000

By Neal Falgoust Caller-Times
October 18, 2005

The nonprofit organization overseeing efforts to renovate Dr. Hector P. Garcia's clinic has hired its former accountant to examine nearly a decade's worth of its own financial record keeping.

It will be the first time in four years that the accountant has examined the finances of the National Archives and Historical Foundation of the American GI Forum. Because the group has not been required to file IRS returns during that time, there has been no need for an accountant.

The foundation came under attack in recent months after allegations of financial mismanagement. At the heart of the issue were accusations that the group's previous leadership allowed the clinic to slip into disrepair, despite raising thousands of dollars at annual fundraisers to renovate it.

JK: All that PUBLIC money and no accountant?

JK: And this prudent idea came about how?

If this initial review raises the possibility of any suspicious activity, at least one newly appointed board member said he would push for a more thorough audit.

"There are real substantive questions about the financial history of the organization," said Juan Garcia III, who was recently appointed to the board of the National Archives and Historical Foundation of the American GI Forum. The accountant hired by the foundation, Adelfino Palacios, is Hector Garcia's former personal accountant and has previously handled the foundation's finances.

The foundation is paying him $1,000 to assemble and review nine years of financial records. The work will start this week and should take about a month, Palacios said.

Also, City Council members will consider an item today to allocate $20,000 in federal grant money to the organization to secure the abandoned clinic and repair its dilapidated roof. The Community Development Block Grant money will be reimbursed to the organization once the work is complete.

The clinic, at the corner of Morgan Avenue and Bright Street, is where activists planned the strategy for the landmark 1968 case Cisneros et. al. v. CCISD, which set the stage for court-ordered school integration in Corpus Christi. The foundation was set up in 1978 as a fundraising arm of the larger GI Forum - which was established by Hector Garcia.

Juan Garcia III said he hopes the financial review will rebuild trust in the beleaguered foundation. He said the results of the review would be made public.

JK: Have the results been made public?

JK: This is a Public issue! We have public money involved. Very much so!

Former Garcia clinic to get roof repaired

Building also will receive fence to deter trespassers from entering property

By Neal Falgoust Caller-Times
November 21, 2005

Work will begin this week on emergency repairs to secure Dr. Hector P. Garcia's former clinic. Those repairs will be the first visible steps taken to restore the building since the reorganization of the group that owns the property.

JK: Why all of the sudden an emergency?

JK: Has not the Garcia Familia been taking care of it while it was in their custody? Before the transfer?

The work will focus on repairs to the roof and on erecting a fence to keep trespassers out of the building. City Hall has committed $20,000 to pay for the emergency repairs.

JK: Why is the City not more involved?

JK: After all, they just chipped in $20 grand.

The clinic, at the corner of Morgan Avenue and Bright Street, is an important landmark in the local civil rights movement.

It is where activists planned the strategy for the landmark 1968 case Cisneros et. al. v. CCISD, which set the stage for court-ordered school integration in Corpus Christi.

JK: Good ole Abe & Janis Jack got CCISD out of paying the million or so dollars just a couple of years ago. D1 says it was 1997.

Juan Garcia III, a member of the board who has no relation to Hector Garcia, said the foundation recently received commitments from state and federal officials to begin the process of seeking historical landmark designations for the building. Such designations would make it eligible for additional grant money.

"This is part of the starting-over process," Garcia said.

JK: Should Juan Garcia practice due diligence for Dr Hector’s sake?

JK: What about Gene Seaman?

JK: HD #33 loophole candidates?

Fate of GI Forum group to be decided

Ram Chavez says charges against him dropped

By Sara Lee Fernandez Caller-Times
March 18, 2006

The American GI Forum of the United States will decide today whether to remove its founding chapter, despite the local chapter's leader saying charges of misconduct against him have been dropped.

Ram Chavez, commander of the Dr. Hector P. Garcia Founders Chapter of the American GI Forum, said Friday his attorney had received word from the national chapter that his appeal hearing set for this weekend had been canceled and the charges against him dropped.

JK: Is there any documentation of the cancellation?

JK: Or, any documentation of the Charges “being dropped”?

Chavez was removed from the national organization July 28 after a panel found he was guilty of improperly removing Founders Chapter members from the organization after former member Willie Davila requested financial documents in 2002.

JK: What was Mr Chavez’s defense to the charges?

JK: Did he follow through with the appeal?

JK: How did this and the re–electing of Chavez effect the Founding Chapter?

"My attorney received a letter from Bob Sanchez that said all charges against me were dropped and my appeal was not necessary," Chavez said.

JK: Can we see the documentation?

JK: Has anyone seen this documentation?

JK: Has this documentation been provided?

But Antonio Gil Morales, commander for the national organization, said Chavez has not been reinstated and that charges against him have not been dropped.

JK: What is the official ruling?

He (Antonio Gil Morales) also said members of the national organization would discuss today whether the Dr. Hector P. Garcia Founders Chapter would be expelled from the national organization.

JK: This brings to mind the story of King Solomon and the dispute over the baby. Here the baby would be the Founding Chapter and it’s charter.

Morales said the founding chapter could be expelled if it does not hand over financial books and canceled checks involved in a 2002 complaint by former Dr. Hector P. Garcia chapter members Davila and Martin Barrios, who could not be reached Friday for comment.

In the complaint, Davila stated that he was expelled after he requested records, including information about $50,000 paid to the chapter after a 1999 lawsuit filed by Dr. Xico Garcia, brother of civil rights activist and GI Forum founder Dr. Hector P. Garcia.

The lawsuit, against the nonprofit National Archives & Historical Foundation of the American GI Forum and several of its directors, charged that the chapters were denied access to money in a building fund controlled by the nonprofit group. It also stated local members were not allowed to join the nonprofit group, which controls money raised for scholarships and runs fundraising events such as the annual Founders Banquet.

Because he was expelled from the national organization after being found guilty, Chavez was not eligible for re-election as the Founders Chapter commander, a position he had held since April 2003. However, chapter members rallied in his defense, re-electing him to the post in August.

Chavez's attorney Gene Ward denied misinterpreting the information provided to him by Sanchez. He said Friday he had confirmed the charges had been dropped with Sanchez verbally over the phone and in writing.

JK: Can Ward or Chavez produce this documentation?

JK: This is a PUBLIC MATTER not an internal matter. Is an inquest, in the interest of the PUBLIC too much to suggest? After all, it is PUBLIC MONEY being mixed in with private sector for whose benefit?

"There was no doubt whatsoever that we were told the charges were dropped," Ward said. "It appeared to show that (Sanchez) had copied several other people with the correspondence."

JK: Where is the proof?

JK: Email anyone?

JK: This is Public Information (due to PUBLIC MONEY), not an internal matter.

JK: Inquiry continues into local GI Forum chapter

By Brandi Dean Caller-Times
March 19, 2006

The American GI Forum of the United States decided Saturday to continue investigating its founding chapter in Corpus Christi, a step back from the possible expulsion it said it was considering a day earlier.

Antonio Gil Morales, commander for the national organization, said the Dr. Hector P. Garcia Founders Chapter could have been expelled from the national organization for not handing over financial documents involved in a complaint by former chapter members. Instead, Morales said the forum voted to look more thoroughly into the incident.

"The authority was given to the executive board to start some due process procedures to correct the situation in Corpus Christi," he said, declining to say what action, if any, would be taken. "It will be resolved in a short time."

Ram Chavez, commander of the Corpus Christi chapter, said chapter members had not heard about the decision and that no one from the chapter attended the meeting in Fort Worth.

JK: Does this not, demonstrate the knowledge of the meeting and that the Chapter had some responsibility to attend?

Chavez thought the chapter might get more information on Monday.

"We'll just wait and see," he said. "If we don't receive anything, we're just going to stick to what we have in writing."

JK: What does Mr. Chavez have in writing?

JK: Can you provide something to vindicate you Mr. Chavez?

JK: Indeed we will defend your position if the documentation is made available and it is vindicating in nature. Even partially vindicating.

Chavez had planned to go to the meeting to appeal a July decision to remove him from the national organization, which is a civil rights group founded by the late Dr. Hector P. Garcia, after a panel found him guilty of misconduct. A former member of the founding chapter claimed to have been expelled after requesting records about $50,000 paid to the chapter after a 1999 lawsuit filed by Xico Garcia, brother of the forum's founder. Chavez also was named in the complaint.

JK: What is the case number and which court is it in?

JK: If Mr. Chavez failed to attend the meeting; did this moot his appeal?

JK: What about the status of the Founding Chapter since it failed to attend as well?

Although Chavez was expelled from the national organization, the local chapter voted in August to re-elect him as its commander.

JK: Defiance,…….. will only drag the founding chapter down eventhough, in the end a point might be proven but at what cost. Pride has no place in this “internal matter”.

Chavez said he was informed Friday that the charges against him had been dropped, but Morales said Saturday that wasn't true.

"He is not a member," Morales said of Chavez. "His final appeal will be at the National Conference in Kansas in July. It has been postponed until then, and at that time the board of directors will vote on the case."

National GI Forum letter requests forms

Documents regard chapter's internal matters

By adriana garza Caller-Times
March 21, 2006

The national organization of the American GI Forum is drafting a letter to its Dr. Hector P. Garcia Founders Chapter in Corpus Christi that may decide the future of the founding chapter.

National Commander Antonio Morales said during a weekend conference in Fort Worth, that included members of the national organization, that the national board of directors decided to send the founding chapter a letter giving it 30 days to produce requested documents related to internal matters.

In July, a panel found Ram Chavez, commander of the founders chapter, guilty of misconduct and expelled him from the national organization. Despite the expulsion, the founding chapter re-elected him commander in August.

"We have some issues with internal matters," Morales said. "We are following the administrative process and constitutional provisions that give us the authority to ask and inquire about specific information."

If the founding chapter does not respond to the letter, it may run the risk of being suspended, Morales said. Chavez had a news conference Monday addressing the possible suspension of the chapter's charter.

He said he was embarrassed that an internal matter had received so much public attention. Chavez and his attorney were to present their side of the story to the national board of directors Thursday, but Chavez's attorney received a letter from the attorney of the national organization saying the charges against Chavez had been dropped.

JK: Is there any documentation that supports the charges being dropped?

But Morales said the charges have not been dropped as of Saturday.

"Now they want to revoke the charter of the founding chapter," Chavez said. "They tried it with me and now they want to try it with the whole chapter."

JK: This is an example of the loyalty and nobility to Mr. Chavez sinking the Founding Chapter of the GI Forum. If they were concerned for the immediacy the most expedient action would be for Mr. Chavez to step down with full honors.

"I'm willing to go to court to fight this," Chavez said. "It's a matter of principle."

JK: I thought the main argument Mr. Chavez makes is regarding it being a public issue?

JK: Will anything positive come out of the courtroom with respect to this issue?

Founding GI forum chapter suspended

Action, taken for failure to provide documents, called unconstitutional

By Adriana Garza Caller-Times
July 21, 2006

The local American GI Forum chapter, which bears the name of founder Dr. Hector P. Garcia, has been suspended by the National American GI Forum.

According to the letter, the suspension was a result of a failure to turn over financial documents requested by the national board of directors. The financial documents were requested in a letter sent to members of the founding chapter last month.

JK: Last Month???? This has been going on since 2002. The records have been withheld and members were expelled for requesting them.

Dr. Hector Day

A decade after GI Forum founder's death, dozens march in honor of his work for Hispanics

By Mike Baird Caller Times
July 23, 2006

Lisa Ann Torres, past president of the Cesar Chavez Committee, another Hispanic labor rights organization, led the procession of flag-waving, banner-toting supporters, peaking over a larger-than-life portrait of Dr. Garcia whose leadership improved the quality of life for Hispanic Americans.

In 1948, Garcia started the local chapter of the American GI Forum, which blossomed into a national Hispanic civil rights group. A veteran of World War II, Garcia was inspired to take action after he saw many area Hispanic veterans being denied educational, medical and housing benefits guaranteed to them under the GI Bill of Rights.

At a program that followed the march, Mayor Henry Garrett proclaimed July 22, 2006 "Dr. Hector P. Garcia Day" to honor the legacy of the organization that led the charge in correcting many discriminatory practices.

Supporters want to convert Garcia's old clinic into a museum outlining his contributions to the community. The effort has been hobbled by financial miscues and vandalism, and so far, organizers haven't raised any funds.

City leaders recently directed $250,000 in grant funds to the education foundation of the local chapter of the American GI Forum but charged the leadership to raise matching funds to restore the building which still displays a faded sign reading "Central Pharmacy."

"We have a year to raise our portion," said Amador C. Garcia, a local attorney overseeing the restoration effort. "We're holding sessions with board members to implement a blue-ribbon committee to raise funds for the rehab."

"It's going to happen," said Joan Veith, new president of the Corpus Christi Barrios Association.

It's been the longtime hope of the association to have the medical facility designated a national historical landmark.

Peter Vallecillo, acting Texas GI Forum civil rights director and director of the Southwest Institute on Poverty and Civil Rights, said the national organization violated the due process of the founding chapter as outlined in the organization's constitution.

"The national board never gave the chapter the right to a hearing," he said.

Vallecillo cited a section of the organization's national constitution that states that a chapter's charter can be suspended "only after a full hearing before the national board whose simple majority ruling shall be final."

According to the constitution, a chapter in danger of losing its charter has the right to counsel and the right to present evidence, as does the national board of directors.

Once a chapter's charter is suspended, it shall remain suspended until the organization "purges itself of fault to the satisfaction of a majority of the national board before it can be eligible to have a new charter issued."

Vallecillo, members of the founding chapter and Cecilia Akers, daughter of Hector P. Garcia, all say no such hearing took place.

Antonio Gil Morales, national commander of the American GI Forum, said he would not discuss what he called an "internal matter," though he did confirm the suspension was a result of a failure to provide requested documents.

Last July, a GI Forum panel found former founding chapter commander Ram Chavez guilty of misconduct and expelled him from the national organization.

Despite the expulsion, the founding chapter re-elected him in August.

The charges against Chavez stemmed from a 2002 complaint in which a former member of the chapter stated he was expelled after he requested financial records from Chavez.

The documents included information about $50,000 paid to the chapter after a 1999 lawsuit filed by Dr. Xico Garcia, brother of civil rights activist and GI Forum founder Dr. Hector P. Garcia.

Vallecillo said the national board shifted the burden of producing the documents to the founding chapter's members. ????????????

Hector P. Garcia Chapter Vice Commander Bob Ortiz said the chapter is conducting an internal audit of bank records to assess the group's financial history.

JK: Gives off the essence of impropriety?

According to a letter sent from the national organization to Ortiz, a chapter is required to turn in all financial records requested for IRS reporting purposes.

Vallecillo said the members of the founding chapter have several options, including filing individual complaints against the national board of directors for violating the due process rights of fee-paying members.

JK: Have not these members been aware of this issue for a reasonably lengthy period of time?

Akers said she asked the national board of directors to rescind the letter suspending the charter, but they did not. She said she was very disappointed with the way the national organization has treated the chapter her father created.

JK: The misfortunate disrespect to the Hector P Garcia Familia is the outcome (a byproduct) of the Leadership and members’ actions concurrently. This is where remedies must immediately materialize. These women never needed to engage themselves in the operation while the good Dr was around; why should they be burdened now? Make things right for Dr Hector’s Family.

"How can you suspend the founding chapter of the American GI Forum and allow other chapters to continue knowing the doctor's family is alive and well and they are still using his name?," Vallecillo said. "This is a travesty within a travesty."

JK: It is agreed, the founding chapter must remain intact. I disagreed to, with the part about using the Doctor’s name due to the fact that the use of Dr Hector P Garcia’s name and legacy was part of the transaction when the building was sold.

Looks like Amador Garcia hung Ram Chavez out to dry?

No?